Comparison
Avalyz vs VibeEval
If your main concern is security — access control between accounts, exposed secrets, missing row-level security — VibeEval is the better fit: it probes these points with a deep scan, while the security checks of Avalyz are passive. [1] [2] If you want a wider acceptance test of the published app (pages, accessibility, performance, compliance signals) with a plain-language report and a PDF, Avalyz is the better fit; the two can be used one after the other.
Need by need
| Need | VibeEval | Avalyz |
|---|---|---|
| What is tested | Mainly security: access control, exposed secrets, missing row-level security, admin routes. The deep scan targets access control between roles, with two optional test accounts. [1] [2] | 13 test levels, each with its maturity stated: accessibility, visuals and languages, performance and resilience; passive security and compliance checks (cookies before consent); partial API, data and business checks. |
| Method | AI agents probe the deployed app from its address, with no SDK and no source-code change; the home page announces that findings are checked by a security engineer. [1] | A real browser visits your published address, at desktop and phone sizes; security is analysed passively, without any attack. |
| What you provide | The address of the app; for the deep scan, two test accounts (optional). [2] | The address of the published app, whichever tool built it. Optional: a test account (by default the test is read-only, and signing in is the one form it submits) and the address of your source code for the static, unit and component levels. |
| Report | Verified findings with evidence and a fix guide; re-scan; PDF. [1] | A plain-language summary, findings ranked by severity, the list of what was not tested, a PDF, a protected and expiring share link, and a « Copy for my AI » version to paste into your app builder. |
| Price | Pro $25 a month, Team $75 a month, Lifetime $249. [1] | $9 a month (Perso), $19 (Pro) or $49 (Premium), no commitment. |
| Free tier | Unlimited surface scan; deep scan: 14 days of trial, no card. [1] [2] | 1 free tests a day without an account; 3-day Pro trial, no card. |
What Avalyz does not do
- No attack and no access-control test between two accounts: security checks are passive.
- With a test account, role-based journeys are listed, not played end to end.
- No native mobile app (iOS, Android): Avalyz tests web pages, at desktop and phone sizes.
Other comparisons
Sources
- VibeEval — home page (method, deep scan, test accounts, finding verification, plans) — https://vibe-eval.com, .
- VibeEval — « Vibe code scanner » page (what the scan checks) — https://vibe-eval.com/vibe-code-scanner/, .